Wayne County breaks law with outrageous copying fees

spiritofdetroitLeonard Arnold is fed up with police brutality, so he decided to do something about it.

Without any journalism or law experience, the 49-year-old Detroiter began combing through lawsuits filed against the Detroit Police Department. To his surprise, dozens of brutality suits are filed against some of the same cops every year.

To begin investigating the cases, the roofer with a modest income needed copies of some of the lawsuits. So he asked the clerks at the Wayne County records division to copy 325 pages, which represents just a tiny fraction of the suits. The cost – $731.25.

“I thought this was a service, not a profit center,” Arnold told me, leaving the office feeling defeated. “It’s outrageous. You’d think they were handing out gold.”

The Wayne County Clerk’s record division charges a whopping $2.25 for a single copy, despite Michigan court rulings that limit the cost to 15 cents per page in most cases.

The cost is so prohibitive that many people walk out in disgust, unable to copy public records that often are needed for lawsuits, divorces, and criminal cases.

The fees are a blatant violation of the Freedom of Information Act, which limits copying costs “to actual duplication, mailing and labor costs.”

The county also breaks the law by failing to waive fees for low-income residents.

“The first $20 of a fee must be waived for a person who is receiving public assistance or presents facts showing inability to pay because of indigency,” state law reads.

Deputy Wayne County Clerk Caven West, who was on vacation today, was defensive and insisted the copying fees are appropriate because they help pay for the costs of infrastructure and storing public records, which state law (FOIA) clearly prohibits.

“When you add up all of those costs, it has to get paid for,” West said. “This is not a business we are running.”

To finance infrastructure and the storage of public records – a very basic municipal service – the county is supposed to use its tax-funded budget of $23.8 million, which has spiked 9.1% since 2011, despite the sour financial times.

“I’m not an attorney, and I’m sure that if we were doing something that our attorneys thought was inappropriate, they would have said something,” West told me.

When I was a reporter for the Detroit Free Press, West prevented me from making my own copies with an iPhone scanner. The newspaper’s attorney, Herschel Fink, worked out a plan with the clerk’s office to provide records for free to Free Press reporters.

But West said that courtesy doesn’t extend to others outside of the media.

In other words, a multi-billion-dollar company gets records for free but other taxpayers must pay $2.25 per page.

“How do you look a Detroit resident in the face and say they must pay more than $50 to get a copy of a small lawsuit?” I asked West.

After a long pause, West insisted – for the first time – that his interview with me was off the record.

“You’re a public servant,” I reminded him.

Before hanging up and wishing me a good day, he said, “I am not to be quoted.”

Steve Neavling

Steve Neavling lives and works in Detroit as an investigative journalist. His stories have uncovered corruption, led to arrests and reforms and prompted FBI investigations.

390 Responses to "Wayne County breaks law with outrageous copying fees"

  1. Pingback: seaside residence

  2. Pingback: Rosi feliciano

  3. Pingback: 金山点卡充值

  4. Pingback: best umbrella uv protection

  5. Pingback: Vietnam news

  6. Pingback: beylikdüzü escort

  7. Pingback: modrzew dlh

  8. Pingback: http://bit.ly/1R3rpYt

  9. Pingback: beylikdüzü escort

  10. Pingback: birthday wishes

  11. Pingback: beylikdüzü escort

  12. Pingback: Piece Of Heaven

  13. Pingback: Www.Neu.Edu.Tr

  14. Pingback: article

  15. Pingback: floating charms pendant

  16. Pingback: viagra

  17. Pingback: Diabetes Destroyer

  18. Pingback: 觀看色情肛門

  19. Pingback: Business Products Reviews

  20. Pingback: podlogi dlh

  21. Pingback: pooler Locksmith

  22. Pingback: Best Reviews

  23. Pingback: 他妈的谷歌

  24. Pingback: iv therapy day spa\/salon

  25. Pingback: Visit Your URL

  26. Pingback: 他妈的谷歌

  27. Pingback: sklejka

  28. Pingback: c date opiniones

  29. Pingback: blat drewniany

  30. Pingback: drjaydani

  31. Pingback: gaming monitor blackhat seo

  32. Pingback: porno

  33. Pingback: Socialr

  34. Pingback: 他妈的谷歌

  35. Pingback: comprar en usa y recibe en colombia

  36. Pingback: HR system

  37. Pingback: 他媽的谷歌

  38. Pingback: iv therapy center

  39. Pingback: fake taxi

  40. Pingback: orzech amerykanski dlh

  41. Pingback: fuck google

  42. Pingback: iv therapy jobs nj

  43. Pingback: fuck google

  44. Pingback: fuck google

  45. Pingback: fuck google

  46. Pingback: fuck google

  47. Pingback: fornir dlh

  48. Pingback: fuck google

  49. Pingback: fuck google

  50. Pingback: fuck google

  51. Pingback: dlh

  52. Pingback: vitamin iv therapy in miami florida

  53. Pingback: Krim Temulawak

  54. Pingback: liquid iv ft lauderdale

  55. Pingback: dental implants Georgetown TX

  56. Pingback: radar detectors austin

  57. Pingback: stained concrete Austin

  58. Pingback: Antonia

  59. Pingback: Kurma

  60. Pingback: making club flyers in photoshop only ClubFlyersPrints.com

  61. Pingback: Martin Lawrence Music R&B RNB HipHop

  62. Pingback: pswonline

  63. Pingback: liquid iv ft lauderdale

  64. Pingback: avast serial key

  65. Pingback: painting company in Wallingford

  66. Pingback: printingvip.bravesites.com

  67. Pingback: printingvip.com

  68. Pingback: vip print

  69. Pingback: Rugby Live Stream

  70. Pingback: top rated air purifiers

  71. Pingback: live trading forex

  72. Pingback: the best marketing and seo company in canada

  73. Pingback: cam girl werden

  74. Pingback: Models

  75. Pingback: deck building Austin

  76. Pingback: cheap sildenafil citrate

  77. Pingback: Free WSET Course

  78. Pingback: clash of clans hack

  79. Pingback: Recommended Reading

  80. Pingback: Full Report

  81. Pingback: hack para clash of clans

  82. Pingback: UAN Status

  83. Pingback: la viagra

  84. Pingback: make money on ebay

  85. Pingback: junk car austin texas

  86. Pingback: instrumental background music for videos

  87. Pingback: austin permanent makeup tattooing

  88. Pingback: handmade

  89. Pingback: Custom Vape Mods

  90. Pingback: Kids art classes mansfield

  91. Pingback: garage door repair Austin

  92. Pingback: decorative concrete flooring contractor Austin

  93. Pingback: south africa grants

  94. Pingback: Scholarships in kenya

  95. Pingback: Buy Beats exclusive rights

  96. Pingback: limousine service austin

  97. Pingback: Austin interior house painters

  98. Pingback: bionaire air cleaner

  99. Pingback: christiantshirts.co/

  100. Pingback: mobile strike tips and tricks

  101. Pingback: edarling

  102. Pingback: Red Smoothie Detox Factor

  103. Pingback: amateurs-gone-wild

  104. Pingback: Cloud

  105. Pingback: Wire Cutting Machine

  106. Pingback: Surviving The Final Bubble Review

  107. Pingback: servidor de mu online

  108. Pingback: Football boots

  109. Pingback: escorts

  110. Pingback: android game cheat app

  111. Pingback: date

  112. Pingback: adult shop online

  113. Pingback: hair transplant singapore

  114. Pingback: cyphrenet

  115. Pingback: california psychics review

  116. Pingback: lake grande condo

  117. Pingback: Obsession Phrases Examples

  118. Pingback: youtube.com

  119. Pingback: chlamydia info

  120. Pingback: Obsession Phrases Review

  121. Pingback: porno

  122. Pingback: Roll up gate repair New York New York

  123. Pingback: The Lost Ways Review

  124. Pingback: jet porn

  125. Pingback: reviews on psychic source

  126. Pingback: clash royale free gems

  127. Pingback: fat reduction pills

  128. Pingback: candy saga

  129. Pingback: New home communities austin

  130. Pingback: Men's Grooming

  131. Pingback: Clicking Here

  132. Pingback: official website

  133. Pingback: porno

  134. Pingback: affordable moving services north vancouver bc

  135. Pingback: china proxies list

  136. Pingback: voice lessons phoenix

  137. Pingback: neuken

  138. Pingback: more resources

  139. Pingback: best pet sitter naples fl

  140. Pingback: Shira

  141. Pingback: clash royale hack

  142. Pingback: porn comics

  143. Pingback: stained concrete floors in Austin Texas

  144. Pingback: Best drones for sale

  145. Pingback: Eulalio Tirado Lizarraga

  146. Pingback: what is skinny fiber

  147. Pingback: Singorama

  148. Pingback: click through the next post

  149. Pingback: Garage Door Repair & Installation

  150. Pingback: pet sitter naples fl

  151. Pingback: Douglas Cotter

  152. Pingback: best pet sitter near naples fl

  153. Pingback: porno

  154. Pingback: porno

  155. Pingback: How to Win Your Ex Girlfriend Back

  156. Pingback: InstallShield performance

  157. Pingback: Indian Entrepreneurs

  158. Pingback: personal trainer

  159. Pingback: hollywood gossip

  160. Pingback: Tulsa

  161. Pingback: Mattie

  162. Pingback: hotels in jersey

  163. Pingback: best forex expert advisor

  164. Pingback: Excel Consultants

  165. Pingback: porno

  166. Pingback: ruletkurallarinelerdir

  167. Pingback: bedava casino siteleri

  168. Pingback: Bowers Tactical

  169. Pingback: globe on stage

  170. Pingback: Workout Clothes

  171. Pingback: dinosaur game

  172. Pingback: Gemstone Jewelry

  173. Pingback: listas de motores de b�squeda

  174. Pingback: Finding The Best most expensive jewelry

  175. Pingback: https://www.facebook.com/sexiercom/

  176. Pingback: my website

  177. Pingback: Plano Plastic Surgeon

  178. Pingback: guest posting services

  179. Pingback: Sacramento compounding pharmacy

  180. Pingback: gap insurance benefits

  181. Pingback: hadoop training in pune seed

  182. Pingback: Latest Tech Updates

  183. Pingback: Body Shop Brooklyn

  184. Pingback: คาสิโนออนไลน์

  185. Pingback: free messenger

  186. Pingback: lease luxury apartment austin

  187. Pingback: starcom mediavest

  188. Pingback: Motivation

  189. Pingback: buceta linda

  190. Pingback: http://kwel.me/56a4be

  191. Pingback: sewing caddy organizer

  192. Pingback: local movers

  193. Pingback: http://cutt.us/I47A

  194. Pingback: over at this website

  195. Pingback: yellow fly swatter

  196. Pingback: Creed - L`Heritage de Rocky Balboa

  197. Pingback: dog walker in naples

  198. Pingback: best mattresses 2016

  199. Pingback: electrician wigan

  200. Pingback: Compagnie de menage ste-julie

  201. Pingback: Thai Porn

  202. Pingback: cerrajeros en paterna baratos

  203. Pingback: Hotel Di Carita

  204. Pingback: Kandace

  205. Pingback: Thai Porn

  206. Pingback: try Me

  207. Pingback: party powders

  208. Pingback: Mckenzie

  209. Pingback: Crazy Bulk Dbal

  210. Pingback: E-mini S&P

  211. Pingback: dessert

  212. Pingback: alcohol rehab los angeles

  213. Pingback: Canberra landscaping

  214. Pingback: storm damage repair

  215. Pingback: SalesEnvy Bonus

  216. Pingback: tenerife property

  217. Pingback: العاب

  218. Pingback: fast food restaurants near me

  219. Pingback: dog training school


  221. Pingback: Federal Forgiveness Programs

  222. Pingback: punta cana kid friendly all inclusives

  223. Pingback: movies

  224. Pingback: terrible parking

  225. Pingback: hcg injections

  226. Pingback: Cash 4 Clothes

  227. Pingback: xnxx

  228. Pingback: real estate brokerage spring hill

  229. Pingback: sticky notes online

  230. Pingback: how make money online

  231. Pingback: bathroom scale that goes to 400 pounds

  232. Pingback: ollas rena ware

  233. Pingback: coaching

  234. Pingback: Kathy

  235. Pingback: Vietnam travel guide

  236. Pingback: Bail Bondsman Tulsa

  237. Pingback: Dr Field Harrison

  238. Pingback: make more money

  239. Pingback: Instantly ageless review

  240. Pingback: WHAT IS CAR INSURANCE

  241. Pingback: big y shopping center bethel ct

  242. Pingback: #3626;ติ๊กทู

  243. Pingback: judi bola online

  244. Pingback: anastasiadate

  245. Pingback: white kidney bean extract impact on diabetes

  246. Pingback: 13x13x13 fabric drawers

  247. Pingback: flat belly overnight program

  248. Pingback: start a penny auction

  249. Pingback: take home pay calculator

  250. Pingback: Best Minneapolis acupuncturist

  251. Pingback: How To Get A Girl To Like You

  252. Pingback: Microcap

  253. Pingback: hpi text check

  254. Pingback: Textr Messenger

  255. Pingback: overnight cat sitter naples fl

  256. Pingback: Jasa Tukang Taman Jakarta

  257. Pingback: austin house leveling

  258. Pingback: in-home cat care in naples

  259. Pingback: bali flag

  260. Pingback: Christen

  261. Pingback: Schoolboy Q type Instrumental

  262. Pingback: cara daftar ibcbet

  263. Pingback: surveillance

  264. Pingback: Make money from home

  265. Pingback: Hotel Di Depok

  266. Pingback: Betting411.Com

  267. Pingback: mejor agencia de publicidada malaga

  268. Pingback: Medical Marijuana Renewal San Francisco

  269. Pingback: hand pump water drinking

  270. Pingback: Probiotics Supplements

  271. Pingback: edgy jewelry

  272. Pingback: british used clothing

  273. Pingback: antispam e.v.

  274. Pingback: event organiser singapore

  275. Pingback: guitar picks

  276. Pingback: sprei murah

  277. Pingback: eating healthy busy

  278. Pingback: Penginapan Murah Di Depok

  279. Pingback: weight loss for busy entrepreneur

  280. Pingback: All Area Overhead - Garage Doors, Repair & Installation

  281. Pingback: Drawing For Kids

  282. Pingback: Expert Lift iQ Free Trial

  283. Pingback: boom beach free diamonds

  284. Pingback: Mp3 Urbano

  285. Pingback: boom beach hack tool

  286. Pingback: movietube

  287. Pingback: singing monsters cheats

  288. Pingback: tenerife blog

  289. Pingback: Olinda Barrena

  290. Pingback: th8 war base with sweeper

  291. Pingback: meaning of abramo

  292. Pingback: austin roofing company

  293. Pingback: search engine optimization

  294. Pingback: Blackcore Edge Pre Workout Review

  295. Pingback: Bail Tampa

  296. Pingback: http://austinsunshades.com/

  297. Pingback: news

  298. Pingback: L’Mage Advanced Moisturizing Complex Review

  299. Pingback: vitamin c serum

  300. Pingback: Best ayurveda packages in kerala

  301. Pingback: inspiration

  302. Pingback: Dental Implants of Austin Texas

  303. Pingback: clint bertucci

  304. Pingback: eyelash extensions how

  305. Pingback: plumbing pipe repair austin

  306. Pingback: history of name

  307. Pingback: hair loss prevention

  308. Pingback: online auction

  309. Pingback: Austin Sunshades

  310. Pingback: sacred 3 trainer

  311. Pingback: kit tattoo

  312. Pingback: Adipex

  313. Pingback: royalclub

  314. Pingback: digital display

  315. Pingback: Raven

  316. Pingback: doll

  317. Pingback: http://pladebarris.calafell.cat/?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&task=user&id=385266

  318. Pingback: led photometer

  319. Pingback: base layout for town hall 9 in clan war

  320. Pingback: Homepage

  321. Pingback: window tinting austin

  322. Pingback: Get More Info

  323. Pingback: pillow

  324. Pingback: apple shooter

  325. Pingback: Peppa Pig

  326. Pingback: local seo minneapolis

  327. Pingback: big girl fucked essay

  328. Pingback: Escort

  329. Pingback: search engine optimization minneapolis

  330. Pingback: obat ejakulasi dini

  331. Pingback: Laser hair removal nyc

  332. Pingback: Embroidery

  333. Pingback: best snowmobile helmet

  334. Pingback: Extract phone numbers

  335. Pingback: Yung Laquay

  336. Pingback: casino bonuses

  337. Pingback: Susanne

  338. Pingback: appliance repair orange county

  339. Pingback: Ottawa personal injury lawyer

  340. Pingback: app developers uk

  341. Pingback: dog playpen

  342. Pingback: league of legends sweatshirt

  343. Pingback: t shirt league of legends

  344. Pingback: ramalan zodiak 2016

  345. Pingback: medora centre

  346. Pingback: bikini

  347. Pingback: movie2k

  348. Pingback: paintless dent repair training

  349. Pingback: curso de detetive profissional

  350. Pingback: Leaflets

  351. Pingback: Best buy smartphone accessories

  352. Pingback: ecograf Doppler

  353. Pingback: Whitney

  354. Pingback: recommended you read

  355. Pingback: esta

  356. Pingback: porno

  357. Pingback: ketones diet

  358. Pingback: chapter 7 bankruptcy carlisle

  359. Pingback: recycle clothes for cash

  360. Pingback: buy t-shirt

  361. Pingback: the best products on open sky

  362. Pingback: groupon chicago

  363. Pingback: banheira

  364. Pingback: guitar picks

  365. Pingback: webcam girl worden

  366. Pingback: http://www.flatratecomputerservice.com/laptop-and-tablets/

  367. Pingback: Manifestation Miracle Reviews

  368. Pingback: xcmwnv54ec8tnv5cev5jfdcnv5

  369. Pingback: ccn2785xdnwdc5bwedsj4wsndb

  370. Pingback: viagra

  371. Pingback: Garcinia Cambogia

  372. Pingback: blue ofica

  373. Pingback: City of Detroit demands up to $42,000 to produce public EMS records | Motor City Muckraker

  374. Pingback: Idea Apps Company

  375. Pingback: carbid very cheap stuff

  376. Pingback: elo boosting

  377. Pingback: www.srkauto.com